The Digital Music Revolution
May 11th, 2008I read a post recently about moving from physical media to digitally distributed music. This kind of transition seems to be popular lately, but I myself am not quite caught up in it yet. Here’s my main reasons.
I love going into a store, holding an album in my hand and saying “I want this”. I love taking that album home, taking the CD out of the case, and inserting it into my CD player. I love reading the booklet while I listen to the music. I love looking at my collection of CDs all lined up in the bookshelf. These things are impossible with digital music. All I can do in iTunes is CoverFlow mode. And no, it’s not the same thing.
But let’s focus on the music itself for a moment. Most of the music that is available on the internet is encoded in MP3 at 128Kbit/s. It amazes me every day how the distributors can get away with calling this “near-CD quality” every day. Anyone who has listened to songs downloaded from, say, the iTunes store on decent headphones or speakers will be convinced that they just wasted 99¢. And the data will reassure them - Uncompressed music has a bitrate of about 1500Kbit/s. So much for “near-CD quality”.
These gripes of mine may be shared by others, and they may be exclusive to me. But I know that these few niggles will not stop giants like Amazon or Apple. All I can do is cross my fingers that some day they will learn how to encode music properly (respect to Linn for leading the way). Until then, I’ll stick with my CDs. What about you?